History of Sayville

By Betsy Burlingame

VRBO Vacation Rentals
VRBO Vacation Rentals

Summary: It's helpful for people considering moving to Sayville to understand it's history and how it has developed into the community it is today.

Sayville, a hamlet located on the South Shore of Long Island in the Town of Islip, Suffolk County, New York, has a rich history that dates back to the 18th century. Originally inhabited by the Secatogue tribe of the Algonquin nation, the area was later settled by Europeans in the 1700s. The community was initially known as "Over South" but was renamed Sayville in 1838, possibly after a landowner, Samuel Phillips, whose middle name was "Sayre."


The hamlet's location on the Great South Bay made it a bustling port for shipping and a hub for the oyster industry during the 19th century. Sayville also became a popular destination for tourists and summer residents, with the South Side Railroad extending its service to Sayville in 1868, making it more accessible. The area's beautiful beaches and charming Victorian homes attracted visitors from New York City and beyond.


In the 20th century, Sayville continued to grow as a residential community while maintaining its small-town charm. The hamlet played a role during World War II when the U.S. Navy constructed a base for seaplanes. Today, Sayville is known for its tight-knit community, historic Main Street, and cultural events, including the annual Summerfest. Its maritime heritage is celebrated at the Long Island Maritime Museum, and the nearby Fire Island provides a scenic escape for residents and tourists alike.


For those living in Sayville or considering a move there, the hamlet offers a blend of historical allure, community spirit, and coastal living, making it a unique and desirable place to call home on Long Island.

About the Author

Betsy Burlingame Betsy Burlingame is one of the founders of BlueBurbia and the Founder and President of Expat Exchange. She launched Expat Exchange in 1997 as her Master's thesis project at NYU. Prior to Expat Exchange and BlueBurbia, Betsy worked at AT&T in International and Mass Market Marketing. She graduated from Ohio Wesleyan University with a BA in International Business and German. Betsy loves to travel and spend time with her family. Connect with Betsy on LinkedIn.


VRBO Vacation Rentals
VRBO Vacation Rentals

With over 2 million bookable vacation rentals, Vrbo connects homeowners with families and vacationers looking for something more than a hotel for their trip.
Learn More

VRBO Vacation RentalsVRBO Vacation Rentals

With over 2 million bookable vacation rentals, Vrbo connects homeowners with families and vacationers looking for something more than a hotel for their trip.
Learn More

New York Forum New York Forum
Talk with other digital nomads and expats in New York on our New York forum - meet people, get advice and help others.

Contribute to New York Network Contribute
Help others in New York by answering questions about the challenges and adventures of living in New York.

Real Estate in New YorkReal Estate in New York

Real estate listings in popular cities and towns in New York.

Guide to Real Estate in New YorkGuide to Real Estate in New York

Advice for people renting and buying real estate in New York.

VRBO Vacation Rentals
VRBO Vacation Rentals

With over 2 million bookable vacation rentals, Vrbo connects homeowners with families and vacationers looking for something more than a hotel for their trip.
Learn More

VRBO Vacation RentalsVRBO Vacation Rentals

With over 2 million bookable vacation rentals, Vrbo connects homeowners with families and vacationers looking for something more than a hotel for their trip.
Learn More

VRBO Vacation Rentals
VRBO Vacation Rentals

Copyright 1997-2026 Burlingame Interactive, Inc.

Privacy Policy Legal